Showing posts with label Post-Ref Devo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Post-Ref Devo. Show all posts

Sunday, 7 December 2014

Smith - The Ritual Burning

So, Lord Smith of Kelvin has, at last, published his report. The much-vaunted Vow has produced results. By my reading and by all accounts (with the exception of NO-facing commentators), it’s a shameful non-event, no less than I expected either.

Opinion divides along predictable lines. From the Westminsterites, Scotland’s promise is delivered, now shut up, Scotland. From Scotland, we’re being offered nothing. Where’s the Home Rule, Devo Max and all that stuff?

Then in the midst of this, a storm: councillors set fire to the document because they don’t like it. Outrage follows. It's the same old smoke and mirrors, the stuff of politics-as-usual.

Now I agree, the fire-raising (into a bin no less) was a bit naff, obvious even. It walked, as some say, into the waiting arms of the voracious Main-Stream-Media. A silly prank. Though hardly worse, as others have posted, than Iain Gray a while ago, publicly ripping up an SNP manifesto for effect. Isn’t that what we've come to expect, the cut and thrust of the 21st Century's sub-standard rhetoric? Aren’t these its props and rituals?

Get over it. We’re back in the days of faux indignation and puff. Truth is, we never left them.

It was Smith himself raised the notion of compost, for environmental reasons (his Green Bank chairmanship) and, setting aside his considerable interests in fracking, let’s credit it as an interesting riposte.

Still, I agree with the arsonists critique of Smith. His proposals aren’t worth a candle. His published report is Brown’s pig in a poke shown up as a slimy reduction of inferior pork. There’s nothing in it for Scotland except pretexts, backdoor cuts, and powers trumpeted but stripped away in acres of small print.

So, composting seems a positively useful fate. Mind you, I’d not be averse to this also being a public ritual not unlike its conflagrating. I’d have a full media circus where the shredded remains of the Commission’s meanderings are layered with rotten veg and dung. Post-watershed, we might even see, from a discrete distance, some anonymous political gardener doing a Bob Flowerdew on it.

Everything changes, everything remains the same…

How can we take any promises seriously when we're still saddled with black-is-white, white-is-black politics? From the mainstream parties and its media, current pronouncements bear little relation to those of three months ago. It's as if none of them concocted a froth of lies about independence. Project Fear was a bad dream and is now forgotten. The Labour Party now appear to have Scotland’s best interests at heart.

Chin music. 

We're still thirled to a Union of chicanery, deceit and backstabbing behind the scenes. Westminster rules. OK? That’s their message to Scotland. We’ll give you a laughable set of new powers, crow about the groundbreaking generosity of it, then do everything possible to screw you.

To demonstrate: no sooner had Smith reported, with the Scottish pittance there for us all to see and lament over, we learn the DWP is extending Work Programme contracts despite this being one area to come under Holyrood control. At the last moment, we're saddled with future obligations to an unfair and untenable scheme. No discussion, no co-operation. A decision made in Westminster remoteness.

And don’t forget, this tinkering is with Smith’s recommendations. Nothing is agreed yet nor in statute. How many more instances of attrition will we see in the coming months? Believe me, the Smith proposals are destined to be ratted on not ratified. Scotland’s punishment has begun.

In these circumstances, I ask myself, what’s worse, an ill-judged stunt or cynical duplicity? The smoke I see isn’t from a few pages going up in flames, it’s billowing from the collective political pants of Cameron, Osborne, Clegg, Cable, Miliband, Balls, the whole lot of them, incinerated by their pathological lies.

Wednesday, 22 October 2014

The Marriage Smith (I Doubt It…)

Well, we had all the marriage analogies in the run-up, didn’t we? Remember, dividing up the CD collection? Walk away from the relationship (i.e. the Union) and you walk away from everything we owned together (i.e. the pound, defence, life as we know it). They were very fond of the break-up blues, weren’t they?

Then we had the threats. You’re nothing without us. We made you everything you are today. Without our guiding hand you’ll go back to your useless old self. You’ll never manage without us.

Then the lovebombing, let’s call it pleading. We were so good together. We still love you. We achieved great things, don’t throw all that away!

Until, finally. We know you want to be more in control of your life. Just stay. We’ll sit down and agree all the things you can do on your own that you couldn’t do before. Just agree to stay and we won’t have to divvy anything. We’ll make sure you have all the freedom you want. But still together!

I know, I know. It’s not about you; it’s about us. We never understood how much we’d hurt you, how much you’d yearned. We’ll change. Honest. Just say we’ll be together and then we’ll talk. There’s a dear…

And now? That was a vow? I thought a vow was, in marriage terms, a declaration of commitment by both parties, usually with some kind of celebrant and usually to a set of rules. You know the deal: do you Wes Minster take Cally Donia to be your lawfully wedded… ? Now I come to think of it where were the political equivalents of ‘forsaking all others’, ‘to have and to hold’, ‘all my worldly goods’. Oh, well maybe that last bit is what the whole thing is really about.

Then the pleading, loved-up sentiment, threats and downright, made-up horror stories all just faded away. It dawned on me, Gordon Brown’s performance was all a bit like the best man patching up a wedding spat, making promises the groom can’t keep. He was a bit pissed. Didn’t mean to spend the honeymoon money in a casino. 

Now they’re all at it, like well-meaning (but useless) friends trying to a sell a reconciliation. He’ll let you keep your half of the CDs in your room. You’ll get to use the car on Fridays. And he’ll look after the money, so just hand over your wages and he’ll make sure you’ve got plenty money for shoes.

But then, when you both sit down to talk about the future, suddenly, the room is full of people. Your other half has brought in a lawyer, several friends plus the minister and the guy from the local supermarket for good measure. None of them are going to agree. Least of all with you. This, you think, is a stitch-up.

Oh, and don’t forget your families. Yours, it turned out, had been mostly in favour of giving it another go. Not by a huge margin, let it be said, because quite a lot of them had been saying all along, enough’s enough. Get the hell out. Now! His family, on the other hand, was always for staying together. Some of them, though, are now suggesting, don’t give away too much. Others are saying, don’t give her anything at all. You never asked us. A few are even saying, get shot of her, get rid of the bitch!

Seems to me that’s where we’re up to with Lord Smith and his commission. It’s the worst reconciliation imaginable. There we were, on a knife-edge. Maybe’s aye, maybe’s naw. We cave in and decide to stick with it. Then this is what we get, a bloody counselor, employed by our other half plus other worthies, not many of our choosing except for a couple of token pals on to make up the numbers, make it look fair.

And the upshot? Instead of promises kept, we’ll get a lawyer’s charter. Lots of new privileges that won’t amount to a hill of beans. You can go dancing any time you like. But you’ll have to pay for your own taxis. You can spend as much on slap but it’ll come out of your pay. You can keep what you earn, by the way, but I’ll be in charge of the family silver including your father’s war medals and I keep anything we dig up in the garden. And I’ll take care of the mortgage, and the bank, and the foreign holidays. Don’t forget the burglar alarm. And the shotgun collection, we’ll keep that in your room but only I can use it. Oh, and if the neighbours ask us round, leave the talking to me. And if you want to ask anyone to ours, check with me first. Don’t want you inviting all the riff-raff in, do we?

Better together? Sod that for a game o sodjers. It’s enough tae gar ye greet. It’s enough to mak ye want yer independence.



Another political fantasy. Well, they started it, with all their marriage imagery and the lovebombing. I’ve just taken it too far. For effect of course. And if there’s a grain of truth in the proceedings… well there ye go…

Also, I cast Scotland as the woman here mainly because the
other half’s attitude is chauvinistic. Typical Tory, Red, Yellow or Blue, in my view. It’s how we’ve been treated all along, like a dimwit, necessarily cast as the unequal partner. I hope the rise of the woman’s voice in YES circles shouts against these establishment attitudes especially loud.

Indeed, if the female persona is good enough for Bella Caledonia, it’s good enough for us all. Mother Glasgow. Mother Scotland. It’s got a deep Celtic ring to it. That’s why, as others have mentioned, we don’t do patriotism here. It’s too macho. Cheesy at best, arrogant and aggressive at worst. No. No. No. Let’s celebrate our Matriotism. 

Wednesday, 8 October 2014

Dear Lord Smith… I Want…

An open letter to the Smith Commission. Thought I'd just get this in at the same time as the big hitters.

Just a passing place…
Dear Lord Smith

As a member of the YES Movement, I obviously wanted Scottish independence, for reasons of social justice, a fairer and more equal society, and to have full control of our economy so we could grow Scotland in the directions we choose. The majority preferred NO and I respect that, but the aspirations behind my own position haven't changed.

The promise of new powers, more powers, for Scotland, in my view, meshed with the broader preferences of Scotland as a whole. Devo Max was seen as the most popular choice prior to the setting out of the referendum and its questions; I see it having as broad an appeal now.

Some politicians have recently suggested Devo Max shouldn't be on the table for discussion. I disagree. The tenor of Gordon Brown's intervention in the final days was exactly that more powers would approach full home rule or federalism. I believe that is what most Scots believed it meant, particularly those inclined to NO and it's what an overwhelming majority now want,  spanning YES and NO. Anything short of it will be taken as a promise broken.


The prevailing energy now in Scottish politics is one of powerful popular engagement, an energy which strongly supports a move away from politics as usual. To demonstrate that, a Scottish settlement must achieve greater levels of transparency and popular participation. The Smith Commission, in my view, must address the breadth of new powers, at the same time, building openness and a participatory framework in which these powers will reside.

Having nailed my colours, as it were, let me say what I demand in the settlement, prefacing it with my own, home-rule biased, view as a UK citizen. The principles of the kind of society I want to live in rest on social justice as stated above. That applies to the Union as much as to Scotland. Independence seemed to be a proper model to begin to achieve it. As we now are, I expect the more powers settlement to embrace a goal of assisting this aim, in Scotland within its jurisdiction and in the constituent parts of the UK, as a model or example. I don't expect it to draw us further into the social divisiveness currently evident in the status quo.


More powers, the powers themselves, must include devolved control of all matters. There's little point in having control of a budget without control of how it's raised or set, nor control of the revenues from which it is taken. For that reason, Scotland has to have tax-raising powers and powers of distribution. It has to control all the revenues and that includes taxes on oil, gas and other energy resources. Furthermore, the principle of transparent and participatory governance should inform any tax-sharing arrangements which send a proportion to Westminster. The detail should be clearly published in the public domain.


Where tax revenues are shared and distributed to Westminster, any redistributive mechanisms (like the Barnett formula) should be clearly set out, shared in the public domains and constructed on a basis of clarity and fairness. All variations in the process should be a consultative exercise involving both Scotland and Westminster. The UK Treasury alone should not be the sole arbiter as it is currently with Barnett.

Pensions should also be devolved fully, so Scotland can develop a pension strategy to suit its needs or to protect, enhance and develop its provision. Broadcasting should also be devolved so Scotland can use it's population share of revenues, including the licence fee should that be retained in Scotland, to fund broadcasting. Whether a spend for public service broadcasting is best served by funding a Scottish BBC service or funding a state broadcaster on a different model should be a decision for Scots and Scotland.

Welfare, since we have a very different view of its function, must be fully devolved. I think the view in Scotland appreciates better the need to support our vulnerable and sees the potential for motivation within welfare if structured differently. This view, I believe, resonates across a wider spectrum of political opinion than elsewhere. We should have the power here to guide its evolution.

On other currently reserved powers, I appreciate the need to harmonise more closely on issues of collective interest. I would prefer to be rid of Trident but in the present arrangement see little hope of that in the short term. Immigration might be as vexed a question; foreign affairs, too, although it's very clear the appetite in Scotland for participation in foreign military campaigns is far less and has a completely different ring to it.

Any settlement, however, must embrace participation and representation: participation that reaches to the grass roots and gives people, sovereign in Scotland, a voice; representation that gives our elected representatives a place wherever powers reserved to Westminster are managed and policy discussed.

Specifically, I expect the settlement to offer direct representation in national and international forums up to now attended by Westminster representatives chosen without consideration of the UK's intra-national or regional composition. For example, I'd expect a Scottish share of EU representation (as I would for voices from Northern Ireland, Wales and such English Regions as require it). I'd expect representation in the governance of the Bank of England in the same way. Since we all own it, a proper, proportionate and representative spread of participation is long overdue.

To construct anything less than this would produce a Scottish settlement which gives with one hand only to take back with another. This would be unworkable as well as deceitful. The solution and the arrangements it springs from have to respect, not the margin of majority in the Referendum, nor the considerable numbers who separately voted so decisively for both NO and YES, but for the 3.6 million or so who became engaged and cast their votes. Westminster must recognise the democratic change wrought in Scotland is more than a brief experiment. It is the possibility of new and empowered democracy. As such it should be encouraged and nurtured.

Yours Sincerely

Edwin



It's not an exhaustive propostion but a plain shopping list isn't being asked for. There are bound to more points and topics. Behind the list and the important matters of full tax powers and autonomy' there is a central question: HOW. Smith and the commission must reflect the democratic potential of Scotland's level of political engagement and embrace a different kind of politics. After all if Clegg and the Lib Dems can come out ginning for the Tories, claiming to be the party of a different kind of politics, surely they will ensure this dimension is part of the new power settlement. Still, they kept that low key while actually shoulder to shoulder with Tory and Labour for, what, three years.

We'll see. In the meantime we should all contribute our views and visions. Make it an outpouring.

Email the Commission at haveyoursay@smith-commission.scot.






Sunday, 5 October 2014

The Return of the Guarantor


The Guarantor. I see him, arms akimbo, cape hanging to the heels of his tight fitting boots, a steely look in the eyes beneath the mask. Here rides the superhero who will see The Promise is kept, The Promise, laid before the people of Scottiya in a yellowed parchment signed by the Triumvirate of the Three, and delivered to them by Loose-Jaw the Brown, the high-potentate (ret’d) of the Black Benches.

Loose-Jaw the Brown, the once-mighty, drew up the promise for the Triumvirate to show how true leaders lead. The Triumvirate stood like prophets of Doom heaping visions of the worst possible on the rebellious Yes-Men all to rally the Noe-Men to join with their cause. Their prophecies, for all their awfulness, drowned each other out, loud, dismal, cacophonous.

In truth the Yes-Men, the Aye-Right brigands, believed in a future where all things were possible. The Triumvirate believed the impossible dream of the Yes-Men could never be. Yet their tissue of horror shredded in the wind of a thousand voices as the Yessers cried out, such was their passion.

The Yessers message went far and wide. The people were wild with it. Behind them stood the Notionalists of the Holy Rood, the Greeners and the Left-handed Children of Toil. Their cry was YES to Freedom. The Triumvirate responded, say Noe for More Freedom Later!

So, Loose-Jaw the Brown, made his stand for Noe. This we all promise! We will deliver more promise together than you could hope for apart. Join with us and defeat the Yes-Campers! Do this and we’ll sit down together, all of us and all of you to make a plan for the future.

In the end, the Noes had it. The Triumvirate sat down on the day after the defeat of the Yessers to make a start. But the Benchers of the Triumvirate had not been asked about The Promise. They demanded different things and their uproar was awful. Some wanted all the future for themselves, some the same future as the Yesses and Noes would have by The Promise. In secret some said, God rot them, we’ll give them The Promise and our left hand will steal it back again. Ingrates and whiners. The deserve nothing!

Loose-Jaw the Brown rode North again to the Fifedom of Fief. There he plotted a new way to secure his Promise. He secretly raised a list of names, a list for Scottiyes to sign and demand The Promise be kept. Once 90, 000 names were on it he revealed it for his own. This he mused will do the trick.

And yet the bickering went on. From the South. Nige the Enrager call the Scottiyes a rabble and brooked no deal at all. The Torrids of the Triumvirate worked to change The Promise’s promises. The Lubbers looked on afraid of what they stood to lose by what they thought was victory. They sharpened their little daggers for the day they’d cut to pieces all the Notionalists and Greeners, all the Left-handed of the Holy Rood, in all the cities of Scottiya.

From the Triumvirate rose The Guarantor at last. With his cape and boots, his dinky mask and superpowers, he waved in the air his delicate hand and said, I will bring The Promise to be. I will guarantee it. I, the one they called the Clegg, have come as the Nick of Time.

The brothern and sistern of the Holy Rood stood aghast. They felt their belts for courage but still stood firm. As one they howled into the South-facing night. Aye, right. Ya bass! Aye, right!



Fantasy following Nick Clegg's emergence as the Guarantor of the Vow, also known as the Pig in the Poke. It's all on the BBC.

Thursday, 2 October 2014

We are Devo

With apologies to Devo*. Altered image © Eidetic Memery.
See James Cook's Article on BBC
I’d been listening out all day on the 1st October for something to mark the start of work on the Vow. Scant mention of it, I’m afraid. Of course maybe there’ll be something by the end of the month. I thought, maybe there’d be a word somewhere in the vast media machine that made so much of Scottish affairs a mere two weeks ago.

Still, it IS business as usual down there, where important things are decided. The conference season is heaving with promise. Ed and Co last week - austerity, ‘save the NHS from the Tories’, reassurance for big business, raising the minimum wage in six years; Dave and Co this week - deficits (when they spring to mind), tax give-aways, ‘how the Health Service will be saved’, terrorism and extremists (rebellious Scots to crush?), foreign wars to prosecute… Oh, and every one gives the nod to us woadies in the heather. The Vow will be honoured. Then silence.


So the media has nothing to report, has it? Apart from William Hague on Radio Four on the morning of the 1st, adroitly reinforcing the promise: it will be delivered. More powers, more powers.


Never mind that a week ago he confirmed to Andrew Neil that if Scotland receives, say, £5 billion worth of extra tax raising powers, the Barnett formula would be reduced by the same amount. Barnett, incidentally isn’t going to be the part of any legislation because it already exists. And, it’s not in statute anyway. It’s an instrument (if that’s the right word) of the Treasury with which, I suppose, they can continue to torture us, or at least fiddle with to do whatever they like.

At the Tory conference, the BBC showed Dave heaping praise on Ruth Davidson for her sterling Tory efforts. No mention of the content of her actual speech, though. In it she said the Smith Commission should rule out discussion of Devo Max (which would deliver everything to Scotland except foreign affairs and the Armed Forces). Now that’s what I call going back on a promise. Significant new powers! She loves Scotland, apparently. She’d do anything for love, but she won’t do that

Late evening on the 1st, the BBC also showed a potted history of the Referendum, How the Campaign Was Won. You could see the slant from the start. Still, Lesley Riddoch remarked in the programme, the BBC don’t understand how balance works, they have no sense of ‘equivalence’. Hence their ham-fisted bias toward NO, one that NO exploited. If NO didn’t take part in debates, the BBC would have to omit any YES viewpoint ‘for balance’. Add to that an ingrained institutional leaning toward the status quo and moribund, slack journalism: there you have it.

No conspiracy, just a sloppy one-sided-ness where no-one asked the deeper questions, nor probed, nor got in behind the issues. Everyone can still say, hands on palpitating hearts, oh, we never even knew we were doing it. Like institutional anything, sexism, racism, whatever, it’s a product of closed minds.

So, even in the lightened mood post-ref, this programme still glossed over so many critical points and moved selectively through the story. Some players were barely mentioned. Derek Bateman and Robin MacAlpine, for example, not al all.

In the end, with a sense the story had been told, but abridged like a Reader’s Digest reprint, I liked Alan Little’s summary. I’d already seen his pieces on Britishness in which he linked that to the sense of belonging we had, particularly in working communities, when we had a ‘British’ industry. It was that, he suggested, gave us the feeling we were in a common project, better together.

Thatcher took all that apart. In the decline, Britishness has withered away, leaving a stump of jingoism and the same saccharined sentiment so many pointed to in their stereotype of the Scots. Britishness an amputated emotion; its only remaining sensation is like a phantom limb: long gone but still as real in the mind, itching and hurting, longed for by many.

Alan Little reflected, the Union still has to wake up to the need for something positive to replace it.

All the promises, pledges and vows don’t address that one thing. As time goes on those who remember the days of British Steel, the Coal Board and Shipbuilding learn to live with their loss or else, being older, take their broken dreams to the grave. The younger Scots only saw their pain second hand and don’t have the same sense of belonging, the more so when Westminster rides down the working people who carried Britishness in their hearts. So the young, the working people are waiting to be convinced. Still waiting.

So the 1st of October came and went. On the morning of the 2nd I read Pete Wishart’s letter to the Speaker of the House of Commons. So far, on the 16th, there’s to be an adjournment debate on the promise, a mere half-hour.

“A solemn vow made by the Prime Minister, the Deputy Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition must surely rank as one of the most important joint statements delivered by the House in recent times. A half hour adjournment debate is, therefore, clearly insufficient to consider all the issues concerning this ‘vow’ to the Scottish people.”

Is this what they call a ‘consultation’? Hardly. Scotland’s back in it’s box where it belongs. Not worth anything except lip service. The arrogance is astounding. It’s a bloody insult.



*With apologies to Devo, of course. Here's their story. Subversive. Oh, yes.


Tuesday, 30 September 2014

Hot TTIP - Letter to Ed

Had an email from Ed Miliband. All about his £2.5 billion to save the NHS. Plus asking for money and my loyalty. Now how could I join the Labour Party after all they’ve done for to Scotland?
Ed  
Thanks for your email a week ago about joining the Labour Party and donating. I’ve been thinking…  
I watched the Party Conference with interest and the very significant announcement you mention in your email. £2.5 billion for the NHS! I’m a bit troubled, though.  
First of all, I wonder why this level of need wasn’t explored, or even mentioned, in the run-up to the Scottish Referendum. I’d have thought it was hugely important. After all, if the threat to the NHS, and I presume you mean the UK as a whole in these post-referendum days, is so great, failure to secure a £2.5 billion extra cash, or a proportion in England alone, would have had ramifications in Scotland as a result of Barnett consequentials. Why did you keep quiet? I can’t believe a politician with a social conscience would have stayed silent just for political gain.

Secondly, Labour sided with and eventually fronted the NO campaign in Scotland for the Tories. Why didn’t you put a coherent plan, a vision, before us? I waited two years to hear that and nothing emerged. Alistair Darling made much of a Plan B for currency in an independent Scotland. I suspect that was to knock down any answers he’d get. But Labour didn’t even have a Plan A. Not of your own. We had a poorly thought out pink Tory look-alike and so badly presented even the mainstream media rubbished it. Now you talk of austerity in the same vein as the Tories and support another ludicrous military adventure. HAs nothing changed? Have your roots shrivelled so much? No we have clear water at last on the NHS, but wait, there’s a problem with that.  
Thirdly, you have a £2.5 billion plan. Before we applaud the cavalry coming over the hill, lets consider. You may find that £2.5 billion lining the pockets of private US healthcare corporations. Not once did you talk about TTIP (Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership). You must know that’s on the horizon. Vince Cable is working on it now, in secret, I presume. The Tories have made it clear that the NHS must be part of the deal (other countries have removed healthcare from the negotiations). You must know TTIP sets out to deregulate trade between the EU and the USA and has implications for every regulation now in place, including workers’ rights, food safety, toxic chemicals, digital privacy. Expectations are that it could be finalised by the end of the year, Too late for the next election. Too late for the promises, even if kept, made to the Scottish electorate in the Vow.   
Why isn’t TTIP your top political priority? You said not a word at the conference, yet here's £2.5 billion to pay US corporations who, incidentally, will have the right to sue any successor government if their bottom line is threatened by democratic changes they introduce to limit this. 
Here are the references, if you’ve not been briefed:
So, you see, I’m uneasy. You’ve just made a promise on the NHS you can’t keep unless you do something now. You’ve made a promise to the Scots you can’t keep for the same reasons. You got in bed with the Tories for what, political expediency, solidarity with the workers of the UK? I think the former, a political quickie and how they suckered you. I think you’ve lost your way, corrupted by the power you once had and so desperate for the fix, you’ll lie with the Tories, the City and turn your back on your roots.  
I can’t join you. I won’t give you money. I can’t support anything you do from here on. I’d say sorry but I’d not mean it. Actually, you should say sorry to a lot of people.  
Yours   
Ed(win)


Monday, 29 September 2014

Slack Water, Après Moi…

There's a feature of tides when the flood has reached its height, a moment, not of actual stillness but of turmoil. Slack water. Then the tide will begin to ebb…

In less than two weeks the flood that brought the referendum to its peak, nearly overflowing into independence, we've seen the same flood increase membership of the YES parties and a huge swell of undiminished commitment to a continuing YES movement.

In Westminster, slack water has been the word. In a chaotic aftermath, we've seen the Vow translated into the English question, hints that any new powers Scotland receives will be balanced by take-aways elsewhere, promises of another five years' of austerity, reductions in rights of protest (fracking), even hints that social media could be switched off to prevent uncontrolled coordination of dissent (Cameron said terrorism and criminality, but what's in a definition?). That came so thick and fast it surprised even me.


Meanwhile, Brown's timetable rumbles on, hardly spoken of. Behind closed doors. Britain goes to war again. Scotland is forgotten, even while the parties squabble between and within about it all.

And you have to wonder, is this the politics-as-usual I predicted a fews weeks ago? Is it politics-as-usual-PLUS? Using the turmoil to advantage, fuelling it, even, to set the agenda for the next step and keep most of it out of sight?

I think so.

I think they are waiting for the ebb to start. The huge political party sign-ups may be disconcerting but the old arrogance predicts it'll happen. They're waiting for it. On it depends the fudge which will be the Brown 'consultation'. Once the proposals for the Scottish settlement emerge (any minute now), the consultation begins. With whom? How? How long has it got? I can't see it being fully public, can you? No, it'll have a gloss of consultation but it will rely on the expected ebbing enthusiasm for concealment.

Image taken from the BBC. Here.
The consultation will be over by November. Go figure.

So the dynamics, post-ref. Why don't we all shut up? Why don't we accept the result? I've said elsewhere (as has Derek Bateman), you don't ask political parties to abandon their politics as a result of a defeat. The Scottish people have made a decision. 1.6 million still believe what they believed and are engaged enough to carry on. And besides, this is about the settlement we voted for collectively. This is about the deal for Scotland, as promised. We all have a stake in that, to see it's the best possible and not a half-baked fudge or a recipe for revenge after our sheer cheek to ask for something different.

So Westminster is waiting for the tide to go out. Hoping. It's true there's a period now where we look at strategies for the way ahead. We look for responses to the avalanche of pronouncements from the South and from our cohort of NO parties as they jockey for position.

I remember, and we all should, if the tide goes back, that's the way of things, and tides rise again. What Westminster needs to recall, is the further it falls, the greater the flood to come. Before the tsunami the shoreline lies bare, before the wave. Before the wave.

Thursday, 25 September 2014

Settled Will or Unsettling Testament

In Scotland, the Labour party didn't win a majority at the last Holyrood election. I guess that meant the Scottish people didn't want them to govern. Now, I'd not suggest for a minute (even in a rant) that they should now desist from proposing policies or framing a vision, even a modified one, of a Labourite Scotland in future.

Same for YES and NO. I hear some regard the result after the18th represented the settled will of the Scottish people. 'Will', I can accept but 'settled' is a vexed question. If for no other reason than the point above.

I know, we've had a referendum not an election. Plenty were happy to point that out or fudge it as required. Still, I saw nothing in black and white, to say the question should never be asked again, that it was settled, as some say, for a generation. It was a referendum, granted, seeking an answer to a point of principle not to elect representatives. There's no reason for the question of principle to have a time of deferment attached to it.


We don't say to a political party not elected, give up and go home, never again darken our doors with your discredited ideas. However much we might wish it, their principles, policies and objectives are their own and they have the right to express them in the political process.

Scotland's settled will, then. 55% to 45%. Pretty near a 50:50 split. About 10% difference between two visions of the future. We need to tease out what those visions were. Lord Ashcrofts poll, strangely enough, analysed why YES and why NO and the reasons differed on the issues most compelling to each. YES put the social justice-fairer society high on the list along with our future in our own hands. NO were unconvinced on currency, unwilling to risk independence, generally in favour of the union.

For me, as aYES, it was clear. I found NO entirely lacking in vision and with no positives for the Union. Even at the last, the Brown package held no detail though, if it had, it could have been the vision so long awaited. I wondered why so late. Now, I still wonder at the timetable, on which so many may have voted NO, as it has nothing inspiring in it and certainly no detail.

So, indeed, the people of Scotland have spoken. I respect the decision but I still fundamentally disagree with it. 1.6 million did with their votes and, I suspect some have already crossed over in the days of fudge in Westminster that followed. This is a matter of principle and a matter of facts, for me. Principle, in that I believe in what YES felt Scotland could be in its own right. That embraces ideas of fairness, justice and an open, internationalist place in the world. It was as much about self-determination as our example to the world: passionate, peaceful argument through a democratic process as an example to troubled planet, including a new flavour of politics, a spirit of co-operation and not conflict.

I feel Westminster have already said all they will about the achievement, having wiped their brows and returned to the run of politics they know. The UK should be proud. We had this debate without guns and coercion of that kind. We did have misinformation, a hostile media and a coalition of parties who gave us nothing until the last minute, who could not or would not make a coherent positive case for the Union based on their own principles. That was shameful.

In the last analysis, I have to say, I will not set aside my own principles. I won't give up on social justice or a different kind of political discourse. I won't tell the YES movement to stand down.

I will use the UK political arena to make these principles a reality. I'll stand firm with my UK counterparts on that goal, just as I would have as a good-neighbourly independent Scot. Solidarity, after all, cross all borders, as any socialist will tell you.

I will continue to expose lies, duplicity and unalloyed spin for the sham it is. I'll call out any politician who tries to varnish the truth for their own advancement. I will honour all shades of opinion expressed by honest people according to their hearts and minds.

If the opportunity to ask any question again arises, I'll ask it. If the chance to ask YES or NO to independence comes again, I'll seize it with both hands.

The people are always speaking.

By Their Conspiracies Shall Ye Know Them

Cartoon by Robert Crumb
I'm wary of conspiracy theories. I worry they're part of another conspiracy altogether.

We've had a few 'dirty foul, ref!' moments since the 18th September. Oddities at the counting, unexplained fire alarms, confusion over YES and NO piles, ballot papers blank on the back. After the fact, these are shown in fuzzy images shared on social media. We all get a bit twitched by it.

I'm certain we need to look into things like this but the key thing is evidence. Investigate, build the case, put up the evidence. Let's face it, the first rule in conspiracy is cover-up. The next is plausible deniability. The third is these people are deluded fanatics and can't believed, about anything. If there had to be a fourth, it's break rule number one, leave a fuzzy trail so you can use two and three against your opponents. Five, if you really want a fifth, is distraction.

So there's the challenge, how to unpick the several allegations carefully and rationally without appearing hysterical and deranged. Be informed, be aware, but above all, keep a calm sough.

Now here's another caveat. All politics is based on conspiracy. We form a world view and from it structure the world as we believe it should be. We choose to interpret the work, events and the people in it according this structure. It colours our behaviour and the way we understand the behaviour of others. Nothing wrong with that. It's the human condition.

We form communities, societies, political parties out of this, of course. We live in communities and societies and conformity is a subtle pressure for most of us. There's room for variation and, all being well, live and let live prevails. Politically, though, the motivation is to mould society and community and to garner the power to do it with. People sign up, toe the party lines and there you have a collective of individuals agreeing to interpret the world in a broadly similar way; agreeing to trying to make the world into their image of it. To me, that's a conspiracy.

An uncritical acceptance of the given world view begets the party hack, the unprincipled apparatchik, the prevaricator, the dissembler and, in the end, the bigot, the zealot and the fanatic. That's why I believe we can never uncritically accept demands of loyalty from any political leaders. We have to make loyalty dynamic, a process of inter-related loyalty, us to them, them to us. Otherwise, political belief and commitment, become blind faith. Applied unconditionally, it can lead to the worst of conspiratorial behaviour. Blind eyes, sleight of hand, half-truths and falsification.

What I believe, too, is that truth wins out because it's self-consistent. It is what it is. Lies and attempts to pervert the truth introduce inconsistency. When what you say is true, or you believe it honestly to be so, whatever you say is basically consistent. Of course, argument arises around facts and interpretation, feelings and their expression but, fundamentally you have no need to twist your story to fit a construct. Liars leak their inconsistency as they try to maintain the shape of their imposed construct. Look at Gordon Brown's body language with Dimbleby. More than nerves, that, the sheer effort of a man trying to avoid the pitfalls of his own fabrications.

That's why I think conspiracy is not the opposite of cock-up but its progenitor. The effort of lying is so great that liars end up exhausted keeping up the facade. They thrash themselves against honesty and fair-mindedness until their mendacity is plain to see. As that unravels we have to be sympathetic to those snagged in their net of manipulation, the ones made complicit because they believed the fabrications and became the second hand proponents of it.

So, in the world of referendum conspiracy, let's be sanguine. Some of what we've heard may reflect our own misunderstanding of the process*, or be within a normal margin of human error. It could be the work of misguided individuals or even some clandestine part of a bigger picture. In the last of these, my concern is: the smartest conspiracy of all would set out to feed our suspicions, leak these fuzzy images until we leap up with anger, fuel the indignation until we're distracted. Then they would deny it, call us deranged, take over the moral high ground and leave us mired in an argument manufactured to kill our focus and energy.

So, I repeat, gather information, find facts, the evidence and quietly build a case. You need to have a grasp of the processes and the rules and be able to lay them out. Until then, keep it quiet until there's enough for you to speak out.

In the meantime, we should watch the collected political conspiracies of Westminster. We should be vigilant. I've no doubt they'd rather we were still arguing with the referee while they're trying to break from the pack for a run at the goal.


* Wings Over Scotland published a piece on this, by Douglas Daniel, an official referendum agent for Wings. He said:
"Believe me, if anything dodgy had been happening, this vile cybernat would have been screaming it from the rafters."
On lying: an article in the US journal, The Atlantic, Is Lying Bad for Us? discusses why.  On page 1, near the end, and on page 2, it touches on how stressful it is and how it distorts the liar's world view.

Tuesday, 23 September 2014

Divides and Divides to Be Crossed

Let's be clear on how Scotland has been divided. More importantly, the several ways…

The referendum split 55-45, a gross figure and, not as some have portrayed it, so decisive. The coarse red map of NO with wee blue things nestled in it does't reflect the truth. In reality the distinction is a pointillist mosaic of red and blue dots. Many towns and villages voted like Glasgow. That isn't part of the 'decisive, settled for a generation' view. Nor does it sit well with the collective amnesia rising like a fog in Westminster as the main parties wrestle for political gains of their own.

Look at it another way, we are a coalition of YES campaigners and voters alongside the persuaded NO and forever NO campaigners. I sense, among the first of those categories, a horrible realisation that the Brown promises of a week ago were just that, made-up muck (for want of a less polite word).

Cameron has tied 'The Vow' into Devo-Plus for all and the English answer to the West Lothian question. He's got a brawl to come with his own back benches but he can sell it on the wholesale destruction of Labour - for a generation. He's already poised to whittle away Barnett .

Milliband is, as he so often was in Scotland (on the street), silent about Scotland. Ed Balls has the temerity to stand up for cuts to child benefit, more austerity, benefit caps. He's more red than Tory by a bawhair, politically a hideous puce.

Clegg is, as usual, liberally quiet. Looking for a fence to sit on. Never mind, he's Orange Book. When the fence turns up he'll sit on it but his feet will be on the side where the rich people live.

Back home, we have the rump of these, our local stooges, the Lamonts, Davidsons, and Rennies witheir attendant Darlings and Murphies. Never a chink of light between, arms linked in a resolute wall of opposition to Scottish purpose. Be sure, that purpose of social justice, fairness and creativity, for all they pay lip service, are diametrically a threat to their corporate allegiances. The division there lies between their covert coalition of dread and our own coalition of vision.

In Scotland, the SNP, the Greens, Scottish Socialists, Solidarity along with community and local groups came together with a positive spirit of unity. We set differences aside to reach a collective goal. And that put an indelible stamp on our political nature. We aren't afraid of disagreement. We are prepared to respect sincere NO voters. Of course, we'll argue, discuss and persuade but we recognise that argument is the foundation of real democracy. We expect our opponents to show integrity and we'll respect them for it.

Deep in the South, I suspect these views have no place. Westminster will bray in the same monotonee as before. Respect is not even skin deep there. It's a shred of scurf, nothing more, brushed aside in a moment of distaste. What's more, in narrow party interests, they'll divide us and divide us to their hearts' content, if it serves them.

Here, we have many bridges to build, between YES and disappointed NOs, and many to maintain. The political movement we grew is nurturing itself, its voice unstilled. That is also the voice we have to project to reach though the rupturing Westminster turmoil.

It must ask questions:
  • Where are the promises of change?
  • Where is the detail you hid from us when you made them?
  • Where is the real consultation about that, for Scots, English, Welsh and Northern Irish voters?
  • Why so late? Did you think you'd get away without offeringf it?
It must provide the answers we want:
  • Nothing short of Devo-Max will do;
  • Full fiscal autonomy - with control of ALL tax revenues, including oil;
  • Social justice - no bedroom tax, end demonising the poor and disabled, no more food banks;
  • Regulate the banks and the City;
  • Regenerate industry;
  • Scrap Trident.
That's a start. But if we don't ask the questions and provide the sample answers it'll all be swept aside in a tide of self-serving politics. The Westminster carpets hide too many demands that have turned to dust.

It's feet to the fire time.

Monday, 22 September 2014

Straw in the Wind

So what's this? Jack Straw thinks we should now legislate so the Union that is the UK can never be dissolved (read it here at the Times). Forgive my foaming at the mouth. Has he any understanding of the act of Union that began this? Scotland's people are sovereign in this whereas the people of England are not. Parliament took sovereignty from the monarch at the time of union but Scotland, as set out in the Declaration of Arbroath, made the people sovereign.

The implications of the Act of Union and the Declaration, as I read them, are that the UK Parliament can't just pass a law to make it impossible (illegal) to pursue independence ever again, without settling the question of sovereignty. Otherwise, any attempt to rule as he suggests, would be a breach of that act and in itself tear up the union.

Christine Graham MSP made a statement in the Scottish Parliament on the subject in March 2014*.


* This is an audio-only clip and it repeats after 6m 30s.

But it's the mindset. Don't you think? Jack Straw thinks of Scotland as a region. In his eyes, the Act of Union eradicated the Scottish nation. It didn't, it merely transferred decision-making to a new parliament in London.

David Cameron, very likely, takes a similar view. His answer to the West Lothian question points that way. It's rather simplistic to think a separation of voting rights, so Scottish (and Welsh or Irish) MPs are barred from voting on purely English matters. This is also regional thinking. It ignores the interplay between parts of the UK (so highly regarded by NO in the Referendum debate) as if purely English decisions would have no implications for the rest of the UK. It also creates a two-tier political process where our representatives operate with differently weighted votes.

You can't argue that the UK is better together as a union and then go on to say we exclude parts of it from voting in the place where mutual interests reside. This is a recipe for discontent if not disaster. Fully devolved regional and city assemblies might achieve some form of parity but, if the UK accepts MPs from all of them, their mandate is to act in accordance with the views of the peoples and regions they represent in the interests of the union. With no exceptions.

The Westminster reluctance here is clear. Full devolution (as in Scotland's elusive Devo-Max) would involve not just tax varying or tax raising powers, but control of ALL tax revenues. Independence in all but name. This exposes the establishment's propensity to fiddle the figures. For Scotland, oil revenues are usually book-kept out of the equation, attributed to the Treasury as a UK asset. Other tax revenues are fudged and finally top-sliced to pay for Westminster expenses, the Lords, infrastructure projects of little benefit beyond establishment heartlands.

With clarity here, all of us would know where we stood but Westminster would have to own up to essentially having its fingers in the till. It would be like your accountant, having long trumpeted his competence and trustworthiness, was exposed as the one who used your funds to finance speculation on the money markets, in military adventures, favouring one client over another and never you.

So, Straw. Introduced the Human Rights Act; also proposed the end to trial by jury of terror suspects; Home Secretary at the time of 9/11, he presided over the Iraq war. He also strengthened extradition rules in favour of the USA, and was accused of making them too one-sided. He was also accused later of complicity in the USA's practices of extraordinary rendition and torture.

Don't get bogged down in accusation and defence here, that's for other forums. Just reflect on the mindset. Straw's is typical, suggesting clandestine deals between hawkish figures, spooky shenanigans on the world stage, and the smoke-filled rooms of Old Labour. Political fog, smoke and mirrors. Transparency. Just a word.

That's the signature of a kind of politics we don't want any more. And it's reasserting itself. Jack Straw is an indicator of the prevailing mood. He's wrong about Scotland. They all are. Being wrong hasn't stopped them before.

Saturday, 20 September 2014

Picking up the Pieces

Something was born two days ago; different offspring but ours just the same. The voice is till there, the passion and the will to build a future regardless. We need to find the energy to carry on.

Somewhere south of here, there's something about change in the air. But the politics of same-old is there too, dragging us back to spin and manipulation just like before. The Great Vow under-scribbled by the Three is already being turned into a Vow to appease Greater England, to become a party-political battleground, a fait accompli for our southern cousins they won't even have two years to wrestle with. Its a recipe for fudge. It'll run into the sand and, in some watered-down form, trickle out roughly on time but awfully deformed.

In that timescale, no-one, English, Welsh, Irish and Scots, not the least, will be consulted. There's simply not enough time. Given that the NO campaign never understood the real issues for YES, where will that leave their new powers bill? The Conservative, Lord Ashcroft, published poll results which show the differences. But the NO campaign and presumably the Westminster establishment they represented seemed to think it was about nationalism, currency, pensions when it was about self-determination and social justice. The first favours the Westminster economic model their world is built on while the other aspires to a social agenda for which economics is a driver.

Worse still, the arguments that will now follow may well set us at loggerheads. It's classic divide and-rule. In the end there's an out, conveniently staged, how can we sort this out with these disagreeable bairns we have as an electorate? Let's just make their minds up for them.

Still, there's another divide in divide-and-rule, the one we've spent two years wrestling over. It's between the Three, between all who align themselves with the politics of power, elites, privilege, organised wealth, and those aligned with people, inclusiveness, openness, responsible wealth creation. YES embodied a real coalition of the willing, brought together the SNP, Greens, socialists with a common purpose and reached out to previously unengaged ordinary folk. No matter what differences we might argue over for practicality, the sovereignty of people in that process was paramount, self-determination and honesty at its core.

I don't believe the Westminster machine can embrace this at all. It's too mired in subterfuge and deceit, too interconnected inside its London bubble to see beyond the finance-media-political cartel consolidated there. I do believe it will dilute, delay and distort the promises it made to Scotland and at the same time pander to divisive forces in England while silencing the concerned majority with obfuscation and distraction.

Here in the rarified North, where we've lived through an inspirational campaign and seen engagement with it, YES and NO, on a huge scale and largely good natured, we have something to share. We have the whole gamut of argument and counter argument, contention and promise, to hold the feet of the establishment to the fire. We are the fire and there are many over our imaginary border who would to join us to achieve the same aims.

The pursuit of social justice and self-determination isn't going away and the turn of events that puts the question out in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, opens the debate there too. If YES goes on in Scotland as it seems it will, the calling to account of the old establishment will remain a rallying point. If it goes on as it might, our YES becomes a YES to social justice, self determination and grassroots power for all parts of this tortured island.

We, in Scotland should be open to that. For our part, we must make the demands now for the 'new powers' settlement. Not the closed-doors sham consultation which will never happen, We have to state clear objectives for it. Not just what it delivers in the terms of Gordon Brown but what it has to deliver as a coherent promise for Scotland, and particularly the NO voters who supported it. There has to be real power. Real transparency. We need to see the economic flows from us to the Treasury and back again, the top-slice retained and what it pays for, We need to understand that tax-raising powers mean just that and aren't a back way to slash public spending and then make us pay for it again at our own expense.

To these ends, the YES Movement goes on. I favour of working with all shared interests in Scotland to achieve our goals of independence, social justice and a new politics. We should also take these issues across the UK since we've been committed to our part in it and find common cause there.

PS 1.6 x 106 is just the numerical 45% - 1,600,000 YES voters. God, I'm obscure…