So, Lord Smith of Kelvin has, at last, published his report. The much-vaunted Vow has produced results. By my reading and by all accounts (with the exception of NO-facing commentators), it’s a shameful non-event, no less than I expected either.
Opinion divides along predictable lines. From the Westminsterites, Scotland’s promise is delivered, now shut up, Scotland. From Scotland, we’re being offered nothing. Where’s the Home Rule, Devo Max and all that stuff?
Then in the midst of this, a storm: councillors set fire to the document because they don’t like it. Outrage follows. It's the same old smoke and mirrors, the stuff of politics-as-usual.
Now I agree, the fire-raising (into a bin no less) was a bit naff, obvious even. It walked, as some say, into the waiting arms of the voracious Main-Stream-Media. A silly prank. Though hardly worse, as others have posted, than Iain Gray a while ago, publicly ripping up an SNP manifesto for effect. Isn’t that what we've come to expect, the cut and thrust of the 21st Century's sub-standard rhetoric? Aren’t these its props and rituals?
Get over it. We’re back in the days of faux indignation and puff. Truth is, we never left them.
It was Smith himself raised the notion of compost, for environmental reasons (his Green Bank chairmanship) and, setting aside his considerable interests in fracking, let’s credit it as an interesting riposte.
Still, I agree with the arsonists critique of Smith. His proposals aren’t worth a candle. His published report is Brown’s pig in a poke shown up as a slimy reduction of inferior pork. There’s nothing in it for Scotland except pretexts, backdoor cuts, and powers trumpeted but stripped away in acres of small print.
So, composting seems a positively useful fate. Mind you, I’d not be averse to this also being a public ritual not unlike its conflagrating. I’d have a full media circus where the shredded remains of the Commission’s meanderings are layered with rotten veg and dung. Post-watershed, we might even see, from a discrete distance, some anonymous political gardener doing a Bob Flowerdew on it.
Everything changes, everything remains the same…
How can we take any promises seriously when we're still saddled with black-is-white, white-is-black politics? From the mainstream parties and its media, current pronouncements bear little relation to those of three months ago. It's as if none of them concocted a froth of lies about independence. Project Fear was a bad dream and is now forgotten. The Labour Party now appear to have Scotland’s best interests at heart.
Chin music.
We're still thirled to a Union of chicanery, deceit and backstabbing behind the scenes. Westminster rules. OK? That’s their message to Scotland. We’ll give you a laughable set of new powers, crow about the groundbreaking generosity of it, then do everything possible to screw you.
To demonstrate: no sooner had Smith reported, with the Scottish pittance there for us all to see and lament over, we learn the DWP is extending Work Programme contracts despite this being one area to come under Holyrood control. At the last moment, we're saddled with future obligations to an unfair and untenable scheme. No discussion, no co-operation. A decision made in Westminster remoteness.
And don’t forget, this tinkering is with Smith’s recommendations. Nothing is agreed yet nor in statute. How many more instances of attrition will we see in the coming months? Believe me, the Smith proposals are destined to be ratted on not ratified. Scotland’s punishment has begun.
In these circumstances, I ask myself, what’s worse, an ill-judged stunt or cynical duplicity? The smoke I see isn’t from a few pages going up in flames, it’s billowing from the collective political pants of Cameron, Osborne, Clegg, Cable, Miliband, Balls, the whole lot of them, incinerated by their pathological lies.
Showing posts with label Smith. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Smith. Show all posts
Sunday, 7 December 2014
Wednesday, 22 October 2014
The Marriage Smith (I Doubt It…)
Well, we had all the marriage analogies in the run-up, didn’t we? Remember, dividing up the CD collection? Walk away from the relationship (i.e. the Union) and you walk away from everything we owned together (i.e. the pound, defence, life as we know it). They were very fond of the break-up blues, weren’t they?
Then we had the threats. You’re nothing without us. We made you everything you are today. Without our guiding hand you’ll go back to your useless old self. You’ll never manage without us.
Then the lovebombing, let’s call it pleading. We were so good together. We still love you. We achieved great things, don’t throw all that away!
Until, finally. We know you want to be more in control of your life. Just stay. We’ll sit down and agree all the things you can do on your own that you couldn’t do before. Just agree to stay and we won’t have to divvy anything. We’ll make sure you have all the freedom you want. But still together!
I know, I know. It’s not about you; it’s about us. We never understood how much we’d hurt you, how much you’d yearned. We’ll change. Honest. Just say we’ll be together and then we’ll talk. There’s a dear…
And now? That was a vow? I thought a vow was, in marriage terms, a declaration of commitment by both parties, usually with some kind of celebrant and usually to a set of rules. You know the deal: do you Wes Minster take Cally Donia to be your lawfully wedded… ? Now I come to think of it where were the political equivalents of ‘forsaking all others’, ‘to have and to hold’, ‘all my worldly goods’. Oh, well maybe that last bit is what the whole thing is really about.
Then the pleading, loved-up sentiment, threats and downright, made-up horror stories all just faded away. It dawned on me, Gordon Brown’s performance was all a bit like the best man patching up a wedding spat, making promises the groom can’t keep. He was a bit pissed. Didn’t mean to spend the honeymoon money in a casino.
Now they’re all at it, like well-meaning (but useless) friends trying to a sell a reconciliation. He’ll let you keep your half of the CDs in your room. You’ll get to use the car on Fridays. And he’ll look after the money, so just hand over your wages and he’ll make sure you’ve got plenty money for shoes.
But then, when you both sit down to talk about the future, suddenly, the room is full of people. Your other half has brought in a lawyer, several friends plus the minister and the guy from the local supermarket for good measure. None of them are going to agree. Least of all with you. This, you think, is a stitch-up.
Oh, and don’t forget your families. Yours, it turned out, had been mostly in favour of giving it another go. Not by a huge margin, let it be said, because quite a lot of them had been saying all along, enough’s enough. Get the hell out. Now! His family, on the other hand, was always for staying together. Some of them, though, are now suggesting, don’t give away too much. Others are saying, don’t give her anything at all. You never asked us. A few are even saying, get shot of her, get rid of the bitch!
Seems to me that’s where we’re up to with Lord Smith and his commission. It’s the worst reconciliation imaginable. There we were, on a knife-edge. Maybe’s aye, maybe’s naw. We cave in and decide to stick with it. Then this is what we get, a bloody counselor, employed by our other half plus other worthies, not many of our choosing except for a couple of token pals on to make up the numbers, make it look fair.
And the upshot? Instead of promises kept, we’ll get a lawyer’s charter. Lots of new privileges that won’t amount to a hill of beans. You can go dancing any time you like. But you’ll have to pay for your own taxis. You can spend as much on slap but it’ll come out of your pay. You can keep what you earn, by the way, but I’ll be in charge of the family silver including your father’s war medals and I keep anything we dig up in the garden. And I’ll take care of the mortgage, and the bank, and the foreign holidays. Don’t forget the burglar alarm. And the shotgun collection, we’ll keep that in your room but only I can use it. Oh, and if the neighbours ask us round, leave the talking to me. And if you want to ask anyone to ours, check with me first. Don’t want you inviting all the riff-raff in, do we?
Better together? Sod that for a game o sodjers. It’s enough tae gar ye greet. It’s enough to mak ye want yer independence.
Another political fantasy. Well, they started it, with all their marriage imagery and the lovebombing. I’ve just taken it too far. For effect of course. And if there’s a grain of truth in the proceedings… well there ye go…
Also, I cast Scotland as the woman here mainly because the other half’s attitude is chauvinistic. Typical Tory, Red, Yellow or Blue, in my view. It’s how we’ve been treated all along, like a dimwit, necessarily cast as the unequal partner. I hope the rise of the woman’s voice in YES circles shouts against these establishment attitudes especially loud.
Indeed, if the female persona is good enough for Bella Caledonia, it’s good enough for us all. Mother Glasgow. Mother Scotland. It’s got a deep Celtic ring to it. That’s why, as others have mentioned, we don’t do patriotism here. It’s too macho. Cheesy at best, arrogant and aggressive at worst. No. No. No. Let’s celebrate our Matriotism.
Then the lovebombing, let’s call it pleading. We were so good together. We still love you. We achieved great things, don’t throw all that away!
Until, finally. We know you want to be more in control of your life. Just stay. We’ll sit down and agree all the things you can do on your own that you couldn’t do before. Just agree to stay and we won’t have to divvy anything. We’ll make sure you have all the freedom you want. But still together!
I know, I know. It’s not about you; it’s about us. We never understood how much we’d hurt you, how much you’d yearned. We’ll change. Honest. Just say we’ll be together and then we’ll talk. There’s a dear…
And now? That was a vow? I thought a vow was, in marriage terms, a declaration of commitment by both parties, usually with some kind of celebrant and usually to a set of rules. You know the deal: do you Wes Minster take Cally Donia to be your lawfully wedded… ? Now I come to think of it where were the political equivalents of ‘forsaking all others’, ‘to have and to hold’, ‘all my worldly goods’. Oh, well maybe that last bit is what the whole thing is really about.
Then the pleading, loved-up sentiment, threats and downright, made-up horror stories all just faded away. It dawned on me, Gordon Brown’s performance was all a bit like the best man patching up a wedding spat, making promises the groom can’t keep. He was a bit pissed. Didn’t mean to spend the honeymoon money in a casino.
Now they’re all at it, like well-meaning (but useless) friends trying to a sell a reconciliation. He’ll let you keep your half of the CDs in your room. You’ll get to use the car on Fridays. And he’ll look after the money, so just hand over your wages and he’ll make sure you’ve got plenty money for shoes.
But then, when you both sit down to talk about the future, suddenly, the room is full of people. Your other half has brought in a lawyer, several friends plus the minister and the guy from the local supermarket for good measure. None of them are going to agree. Least of all with you. This, you think, is a stitch-up.
Oh, and don’t forget your families. Yours, it turned out, had been mostly in favour of giving it another go. Not by a huge margin, let it be said, because quite a lot of them had been saying all along, enough’s enough. Get the hell out. Now! His family, on the other hand, was always for staying together. Some of them, though, are now suggesting, don’t give away too much. Others are saying, don’t give her anything at all. You never asked us. A few are even saying, get shot of her, get rid of the bitch!
Seems to me that’s where we’re up to with Lord Smith and his commission. It’s the worst reconciliation imaginable. There we were, on a knife-edge. Maybe’s aye, maybe’s naw. We cave in and decide to stick with it. Then this is what we get, a bloody counselor, employed by our other half plus other worthies, not many of our choosing except for a couple of token pals on to make up the numbers, make it look fair.
And the upshot? Instead of promises kept, we’ll get a lawyer’s charter. Lots of new privileges that won’t amount to a hill of beans. You can go dancing any time you like. But you’ll have to pay for your own taxis. You can spend as much on slap but it’ll come out of your pay. You can keep what you earn, by the way, but I’ll be in charge of the family silver including your father’s war medals and I keep anything we dig up in the garden. And I’ll take care of the mortgage, and the bank, and the foreign holidays. Don’t forget the burglar alarm. And the shotgun collection, we’ll keep that in your room but only I can use it. Oh, and if the neighbours ask us round, leave the talking to me. And if you want to ask anyone to ours, check with me first. Don’t want you inviting all the riff-raff in, do we?
Better together? Sod that for a game o sodjers. It’s enough tae gar ye greet. It’s enough to mak ye want yer independence.
Another political fantasy. Well, they started it, with all their marriage imagery and the lovebombing. I’ve just taken it too far. For effect of course. And if there’s a grain of truth in the proceedings… well there ye go…
Also, I cast Scotland as the woman here mainly because the other half’s attitude is chauvinistic. Typical Tory, Red, Yellow or Blue, in my view. It’s how we’ve been treated all along, like a dimwit, necessarily cast as the unequal partner. I hope the rise of the woman’s voice in YES circles shouts against these establishment attitudes especially loud.
Indeed, if the female persona is good enough for Bella Caledonia, it’s good enough for us all. Mother Glasgow. Mother Scotland. It’s got a deep Celtic ring to it. That’s why, as others have mentioned, we don’t do patriotism here. It’s too macho. Cheesy at best, arrogant and aggressive at worst. No. No. No. Let’s celebrate our Matriotism.
Wednesday, 8 October 2014
Dear Lord Smith… I Want…
An open letter to the Smith Commission. Thought I'd just get this in at the same time as the big hitters.
Dear Lord Smith
As a member of the YES Movement, I obviously wanted Scottish independence, for reasons of social justice, a fairer and more equal society, and to have full control of our economy so we could grow Scotland in the directions we choose. The majority preferred NO and I respect that, but the aspirations behind my own position haven't changed.
The promise of new powers, more powers, for Scotland, in my view, meshed with the broader preferences of Scotland as a whole. Devo Max was seen as the most popular choice prior to the setting out of the referendum and its questions; I see it having as broad an appeal now.
Some politicians have recently suggested Devo Max shouldn't be on the table for discussion. I disagree. The tenor of Gordon Brown's intervention in the final days was exactly that more powers would approach full home rule or federalism. I believe that is what most Scots believed it meant, particularly those inclined to NO and it's what an overwhelming majority now want, spanning YES and NO. Anything short of it will be taken as a promise broken.
The prevailing energy now in Scottish politics is one of powerful popular engagement, an energy which strongly supports a move away from politics as usual. To demonstrate that, a Scottish settlement must achieve greater levels of transparency and popular participation. The Smith Commission, in my view, must address the breadth of new powers, at the same time, building openness and a participatory framework in which these powers will reside.
Having nailed my colours, as it were, let me say what I demand in the settlement, prefacing it with my own, home-rule biased, view as a UK citizen. The principles of the kind of society I want to live in rest on social justice as stated above. That applies to the Union as much as to Scotland. Independence seemed to be a proper model to begin to achieve it. As we now are, I expect the more powers settlement to embrace a goal of assisting this aim, in Scotland within its jurisdiction and in the constituent parts of the UK, as a model or example. I don't expect it to draw us further into the social divisiveness currently evident in the status quo.
More powers, the powers themselves, must include devolved control of all matters. There's little point in having control of a budget without control of how it's raised or set, nor control of the revenues from which it is taken. For that reason, Scotland has to have tax-raising powers and powers of distribution. It has to control all the revenues and that includes taxes on oil, gas and other energy resources. Furthermore, the principle of transparent and participatory governance should inform any tax-sharing arrangements which send a proportion to Westminster. The detail should be clearly published in the public domain.
Edwin
It's not an exhaustive propostion but a plain shopping list isn't being asked for. There are bound to more points and topics. Behind the list and the important matters of full tax powers and autonomy' there is a central question: HOW. Smith and the commission must reflect the democratic potential of Scotland's level of political engagement and embrace a different kind of politics. After all if Clegg and the Lib Dems can come out ginning for the Tories, claiming to be the party of a different kind of politics, surely they will ensure this dimension is part of the new power settlement. Still, they kept that low key while actually shoulder to shoulder with Tory and Labour for, what, three years.
We'll see. In the meantime we should all contribute our views and visions. Make it an outpouring.
Email the Commission at haveyoursay@smith-commission.scot.
![]() |
| Just a passing place… |
As a member of the YES Movement, I obviously wanted Scottish independence, for reasons of social justice, a fairer and more equal society, and to have full control of our economy so we could grow Scotland in the directions we choose. The majority preferred NO and I respect that, but the aspirations behind my own position haven't changed.
The promise of new powers, more powers, for Scotland, in my view, meshed with the broader preferences of Scotland as a whole. Devo Max was seen as the most popular choice prior to the setting out of the referendum and its questions; I see it having as broad an appeal now.
Some politicians have recently suggested Devo Max shouldn't be on the table for discussion. I disagree. The tenor of Gordon Brown's intervention in the final days was exactly that more powers would approach full home rule or federalism. I believe that is what most Scots believed it meant, particularly those inclined to NO and it's what an overwhelming majority now want, spanning YES and NO. Anything short of it will be taken as a promise broken.
The prevailing energy now in Scottish politics is one of powerful popular engagement, an energy which strongly supports a move away from politics as usual. To demonstrate that, a Scottish settlement must achieve greater levels of transparency and popular participation. The Smith Commission, in my view, must address the breadth of new powers, at the same time, building openness and a participatory framework in which these powers will reside.
Having nailed my colours, as it were, let me say what I demand in the settlement, prefacing it with my own, home-rule biased, view as a UK citizen. The principles of the kind of society I want to live in rest on social justice as stated above. That applies to the Union as much as to Scotland. Independence seemed to be a proper model to begin to achieve it. As we now are, I expect the more powers settlement to embrace a goal of assisting this aim, in Scotland within its jurisdiction and in the constituent parts of the UK, as a model or example. I don't expect it to draw us further into the social divisiveness currently evident in the status quo.
More powers, the powers themselves, must include devolved control of all matters. There's little point in having control of a budget without control of how it's raised or set, nor control of the revenues from which it is taken. For that reason, Scotland has to have tax-raising powers and powers of distribution. It has to control all the revenues and that includes taxes on oil, gas and other energy resources. Furthermore, the principle of transparent and participatory governance should inform any tax-sharing arrangements which send a proportion to Westminster. The detail should be clearly published in the public domain.
Where tax revenues are shared and distributed to Westminster, any redistributive mechanisms (like the Barnett formula) should be clearly set out, shared in the public domains and constructed on a basis of clarity and fairness. All variations in the process should be a consultative exercise involving both Scotland and Westminster. The UK Treasury alone should not be the sole arbiter as it is currently with Barnett.
Pensions should also be devolved fully, so Scotland can develop a pension strategy to suit its needs or to protect, enhance and develop its provision. Broadcasting should also be devolved so Scotland can use it's population share of revenues, including the licence fee should that be retained in Scotland, to fund broadcasting. Whether a spend for public service broadcasting is best served by funding a Scottish BBC service or funding a state broadcaster on a different model should be a decision for Scots and Scotland.
Welfare, since we have a very different view of its function, must be fully devolved. I think the view in Scotland appreciates better the need to support our vulnerable and sees the potential for motivation within welfare if structured differently. This view, I believe, resonates across a wider spectrum of political opinion than elsewhere. We should have the power here to guide its evolution.
On other currently reserved powers, I appreciate the need to harmonise more closely on issues of collective interest. I would prefer to be rid of Trident but in the present arrangement see little hope of that in the short term. Immigration might be as vexed a question; foreign affairs, too, although it's very clear the appetite in Scotland for participation in foreign military campaigns is far less and has a completely different ring to it.
Any settlement, however, must embrace participation and representation: participation that reaches to the grass roots and gives people, sovereign in Scotland, a voice; representation that gives our elected representatives a place wherever powers reserved to Westminster are managed and policy discussed.
Specifically, I expect the settlement to offer direct representation in national and international forums up to now attended by Westminster representatives chosen without consideration of the UK's intra-national or regional composition. For example, I'd expect a Scottish share of EU representation (as I would for voices from Northern Ireland, Wales and such English Regions as require it). I'd expect representation in the governance of the Bank of England in the same way. Since we all own it, a proper, proportionate and representative spread of participation is long overdue.
To construct anything less than this would produce a Scottish settlement which gives with one hand only to take back with another. This would be unworkable as well as deceitful. The solution and the arrangements it springs from have to respect, not the margin of majority in the Referendum, nor the considerable numbers who separately voted so decisively for both NO and YES, but for the 3.6 million or so who became engaged and cast their votes. Westminster must recognise the democratic change wrought in Scotland is more than a brief experiment. It is the possibility of new and empowered democracy. As such it should be encouraged and nurtured.
Yours Sincerely
Pensions should also be devolved fully, so Scotland can develop a pension strategy to suit its needs or to protect, enhance and develop its provision. Broadcasting should also be devolved so Scotland can use it's population share of revenues, including the licence fee should that be retained in Scotland, to fund broadcasting. Whether a spend for public service broadcasting is best served by funding a Scottish BBC service or funding a state broadcaster on a different model should be a decision for Scots and Scotland.
Welfare, since we have a very different view of its function, must be fully devolved. I think the view in Scotland appreciates better the need to support our vulnerable and sees the potential for motivation within welfare if structured differently. This view, I believe, resonates across a wider spectrum of political opinion than elsewhere. We should have the power here to guide its evolution.
On other currently reserved powers, I appreciate the need to harmonise more closely on issues of collective interest. I would prefer to be rid of Trident but in the present arrangement see little hope of that in the short term. Immigration might be as vexed a question; foreign affairs, too, although it's very clear the appetite in Scotland for participation in foreign military campaigns is far less and has a completely different ring to it.
Any settlement, however, must embrace participation and representation: participation that reaches to the grass roots and gives people, sovereign in Scotland, a voice; representation that gives our elected representatives a place wherever powers reserved to Westminster are managed and policy discussed.
Specifically, I expect the settlement to offer direct representation in national and international forums up to now attended by Westminster representatives chosen without consideration of the UK's intra-national or regional composition. For example, I'd expect a Scottish share of EU representation (as I would for voices from Northern Ireland, Wales and such English Regions as require it). I'd expect representation in the governance of the Bank of England in the same way. Since we all own it, a proper, proportionate and representative spread of participation is long overdue.
To construct anything less than this would produce a Scottish settlement which gives with one hand only to take back with another. This would be unworkable as well as deceitful. The solution and the arrangements it springs from have to respect, not the margin of majority in the Referendum, nor the considerable numbers who separately voted so decisively for both NO and YES, but for the 3.6 million or so who became engaged and cast their votes. Westminster must recognise the democratic change wrought in Scotland is more than a brief experiment. It is the possibility of new and empowered democracy. As such it should be encouraged and nurtured.
Yours Sincerely
Edwin
It's not an exhaustive propostion but a plain shopping list isn't being asked for. There are bound to more points and topics. Behind the list and the important matters of full tax powers and autonomy' there is a central question: HOW. Smith and the commission must reflect the democratic potential of Scotland's level of political engagement and embrace a different kind of politics. After all if Clegg and the Lib Dems can come out ginning for the Tories, claiming to be the party of a different kind of politics, surely they will ensure this dimension is part of the new power settlement. Still, they kept that low key while actually shoulder to shoulder with Tory and Labour for, what, three years.
We'll see. In the meantime we should all contribute our views and visions. Make it an outpouring.
Email the Commission at haveyoursay@smith-commission.scot.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



