Showing posts with label Scottish Labour. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scottish Labour. Show all posts

Sunday, 28 June 2015

Hireling Traitor's Wages


…wrought now by a coward few,
For hireling traitor's wages…*
Let's just talk about treachery for a minute. Now that Scottish Labour have descended into the pits of stupidity and compiled clypegate.

Here we have a document, so amateurish in its construction as to defy belief that it was put together by a serious political party with any serious purpose.

I'll actually begin by saying, on first reading it, I found a handful of folk publishing tweets using language that would sound commonplace in an energetic pub discussion. Not the language of political discourse, I grant you, but the cut and thrust of rowdy, slightly pissed rantings later on of a Saturday. In fact, I'd expect the Labour Party's founders in smoke-filled rooms and public meetings back in the day would have given as good as they got in similar terms and called it 'part of the struggle'.

Now, I don't tweet (canny hack it) but I Facebook and blog and some of the terms of endearment I've seen bandied isn't to my taste. But, hey, I'm used to conversations with a few expletives. The clypegate revelations are little different in tone, milder, if I'm honest. I've heard much worse on the tweety tongues of the other side. Vile cyber-bollocks, maybe, but I'm thick-skinned. Scottish Labour are not, it would seem. Or else they're disingenuous and, in the footballing manner, taking the sympathy dive.

But treachery. That struck me. Reading the document and the highlighted terms picked out for all to gasp at I found the word 'traitor' seemed most prevalent. Now against so much abuse I wondered at how come that's the word to get singled out.

So I looked up traitor and found this definition:



Note this definition (first to appear on a Google search, by the way) extends the term to betrayal of a friend, cause or principle. Of course, it has a patriotic nuance, much favoured by jingoists and nationalists of many flavours (Brit-nat not the least). It's susceptible to this interpretation in many of the clypegate tweets but I think you can equally read political betrayal into many of them.

I say this because Labour collectively or as individuals can be called 'traitors' for the simple reason of the political betrayal of their own principles, their working class cause and, in this instance, all of these in the social and geographic context of Scotland. To strip that away and just wave the 'see the vicious nationalists' flag is thoroughly cheap. A mere political trick, one belonging firmly in the politics of the past that still grinds away in Westminster.

So, I come simply to conclude Scottish Labour and, because they're inseparable from their southern masters, the entire Labour Party are traitors. Forget the patriot spin, because that's the Tory, right-wing mantra. Labour have betrayed their working class roots, they've sacrificed their principles and no longer even bother to put up any opposition in Westminster.

In Scotland, as I've said here before, the antecedents of the labour movement, Hardie, MacLean, Aldred, Shinwell, must be birling in their graves. Too many following them have worn Labour colours to find their way to the comfortable benches of power and taken the Queen's shuln for their trouble. They bought into the establishment. Their betrayal, in that regard, is not only of Scotland but of the entire UK nation of working people, of the people whose interests lie at the heart of the Labour cause. They are now abandoned. By the above definition, this is treachery and those who are responsible are traitors.

The use of these terms, traitor, quisling, and the like isn't an insult, it's a description of an insult: the actions of the Labour party itself. They have made themselves quislings by colluding with their opponents, the Tories and Liberal Democrats, in the referendum. 'Quisling, as you'll note is included in the dictionary definition above (and others), as synonymous with 'traitor' extending the meaning beyond specific military conflicts into general political behaviour. I might as well further describe them as 'Benedict Arnolds', from the actions of the American defector who betrayed his own side in favour of the British in1780.



I'll go further and extend my own insult to Labour in the manner of the Norwegians at the time of Vidkun Quisling. They referred to him as Vidkjent Usling (well-known wretch). Scottish Labour, in particular, will remain weel-kent vratches in my book until they wake up to reality. They really must now try to understand the anger coming at them. Much of it is in poor taste but fighting to correct the expression without exploring the anger itself is pure self-delusion. I like to think the SNP and the Yes movement actually understand why some express their anger and fear about independence so vigorously and so crudely. I don't get any feeling that Labour see any value in pursuing such an enquiry. It's time they did. Then they might move on to formulate some policy and principle for the future.

Without it they'll simply flounder. Asinine stunts like the clypegate scribble will only dig them deeper in the mire.

* Robert Burns - A Parcel of Rogues

Friday, 1 May 2015

The Last Milisecond

Well, thanks, Mr Miliband. It’s pretty clear you’ve written Scotland off. We knew already you’d not enter a coalition or confidence and supply deal with the SNP. You very forcefully made the point though when pressed you didn’t rule out coincidental vote-by-vote support. You’d present a Queen’s Speech in the hope (or expectation) you get the support to push it through.



Behind what did seem like a tough-it-out push-back (backtracked when faced with the interpretation that Labour would rather have the Tories in power than deal in any way with the SNP) there was a more telling point. The differences between the parties mentioned were Trident and austerity. On the latter the message was clear. Labour fundamentally disagrees with the SNP on austerity.

Economists, Paul Krugman, for example, (see the Austerity Delusion in the Guardian) are already saying the harsh deficit reduction strategy has fallen our of political fashion. It’s bad for growth and prolongs stagnation in the economy. An anti-austerity position is a legitimate fiscal approach. Labour clearly remain thirled to the same old challenged economic doctrine. As party of the left, working people and the poor (supposedly), I’d expect them to seize on alternatives to austerity and pursue them. But no. They’re as intransigent as the Tories. Either because their ideologies have, in fact, merged or because they’re just too dogmantic to change.

So Ed Miliband has, cut himself and Labour loose from Scotland. His firm stance is actually two things in one: a pitch to English voters who have been media-ed into fear of an SNP agenda and an attempt to scare any Scottish Labour defectors that an SNP vote won’t deliver Labour nationally. The first may work to an extent, although I’ve seen tweets and posts showing English Labour voters saying, on the strength of last night, not any more. On the second, I still don’t think Labour get it.

Scots want a distinct Scottish voice in Westminster, not about independence, but about Scotland in the UK. Labour betrayed its constituency here in how it stood beside the Tories over independence. The task now should have been to win back trust but their campaign simply continued the fear rhetoric, never let up about the referendum and attached an ‘SNP bad’ tag line on everything to the exclusion of  clear policy.

I wondered, what would it have taken for Labour to have found a mature political way to deal with the SNP’s rise? I fantasised, maybe a simple recognition that there’s common ground on some issues. On fundamental political principles there surely is. Why not simply acknowledge the key differences, the red lines if you like? Trident on the SNP side, the mechanics of debt reduction and fiscal autonomy on the other: mature parties accepting their areas for accommodation while pursuing a socially-just, shared agenda.

I could hear lines like: we can work with the SNP. We differ on some issues but I’d want to persuade them to modify their approach for the sake of progress. Or on independence. If we work together, we’d like to think, we can show the SNP how our strong voices in the Union might achieve what we all want. We’d try to demonstrate independence isn’t a necessity…

No such words from Labour. Yet how hard could it be to modify the mantra? From the SNP, I hear much more openness, an openness which is treated with derision. It seems you can’t leave room to accommodate future developments, to negotiate and adjust to the partnerships they demand. Maybe that’s the difference. Labour and the Tories, all the main Westminster parties don’t understand co-operative politics. They don’t seem how to be clearly and firmly different but to choose to work with others nevertheless. That was misunderstood in the referendum debate and is misunderstood now.

As a relief from watching Ed being tough and reading tweet and counter-tweet on what it all meant, I caught up on Sally Magnusson interviewing Jim Murphy. This what I teased out there.

Murphy reiterated Labour’s unwillingness to work with the SNP and how that could allow the Tories to remaining in power. When pressed he said, ‘of course we’d work with the SNP. But it would be from the back benches in opposition.’

I could only gape. In the event, when the Tories’ Queen’s Speech comes before Parliament, would Labour back it?  I mean, when the SNP vote against it, shouldn’t Labour do likewise so the Tories can’t command a majority. A second election would follow, or else another party (such as Labour) or another group of parties would bid to form a government with a working majority.

To even hint Labour and SNP in opposition mightn’t vote together on this must mean Labour have contemplated voting with the Tories or abstaining en masse.

Either that or is there a secret coalition of austerity parties in the wings. Imagine that: a Labour-Tory coalition. Trouble is it’s not as unthinkable as it used to be. The seas would all run dry first. But then, if there’s a tsunami coming… You know what that means.

Tuesday, 16 December 2014

Murph the Smurf

I admit it’s an obvious jibe, a play on the name. The illustrative potential was too much to resist.

Apart from being able to belittle the new Labour (or is that New Labour?) leader in Scotland through comparison with cheap cartoon Euro-pop figures, their underlying colouring was too appropriate. The taint of blue is an indelible stain Labour has to remove.

For me, before the referendum, Jim Murphy was one of my least favourite politicians. During it, I saw nothing to make me feel any different. I find Murphy embodies a kind of political bombast typical of Labour. His is the hustings equivalent of sound torture. That blaring music played incessantly to unsettle enemies under siege. Or night-time heavy metal played to terror suspects in their Guantanamo hotels.

It’s the prefab one-liners and the stock phrases pumped out like vacuum-packed spin to rally the faithful and make the enemies of New Labour shudder - they ring hollow to my ears.

I’m not going to forget the referendum with Murphy somewhere in the mix peddling vitriol and quarter-truths. Neither he nor his party offered any positive vision of the future. All they had was hatred of SNP and the notion of independence on one hand and a misplaced faith in the union on the other. This they held on to like a comfort blanket, either with their thumbs in their mouths or, more likely, fingers in their ears. La-la-la. Please don’t confuse us with facts.

Facts, as we found out, weren’t a currency they used.

Predictably, in the aftermath, Jim has risen to the top, or should I say surface. He’s elevated by his obvious talent, at least with respect to mediocrity of his peers. Either that, or he’s an example of a Scots aphorism often quoted near sewer outlets, referencing coprological specific gravity…

But now he’s making pronouncements. We’re to expect the fruition of Scottish Labour’s very own Clause Four moment, a declaration of purpose which will alter the political landscape. Murphy emphasises patriotism over nationalism and sets it in the context of the British union, of course. He’s going to bind Scottish Labour to social justice, fairness and equality. He’s putting Scotland first.

At least for now…

If I actually believed it, I’d applaud his Damascene conversion. I wonder, though, where these principles were when Murphy was most vocal in the other direction and standing, brass neck by brass neck, with the Tories and Lib-Dems.

He didn’t put Scotland first then. He didn’t listen to Scottish voices. I say that, not because he opposed independence, but because he refused to see how the objectives he now espouses were and still are part of the independence vision. He wilfully refused, to the point of disrespect and blatant lying.

He didn’t get it then and he doesn’t get it now. These ideals are fundamental to Scotland’s vision of its future. They’re shared, as Murphy no doubt knows, by more than just the 45%. He has a whole mountain to climb. He knows full well he needs to convince Yes and No supporters alike of the Labour Party’s integrity.

Just how will he erase Labour’s past support for the establishment (Tory) position? Social justice took a back seat then. Murphy is going to have to demonstrate that his known capacity for expediency won’t turn him into an unprincipled quisling again. More than that, he has to show that Scottish Labour will be allowed to choose a path independent of their London masters (for such they remain). He says he’s committed to it but we’ve heard that one before.

Anyway, as Lesley Riddoch said today in the Scotsman, the issues Murphy needs to stand firm on aren’t Scottish ones. They’re about challenging Labour in Westminster on austerity, immigration and leaving Europe. This is where the social justice agenda really plays out. Without independence, we’re in it together. Scottish Labour can’t pretend the independence they opposed has suddenly happened for them as a party. They, and that means Murphy, have to take the fight to London, not sit it out.

Indeed, you might view the ‘Scottish Labour is independent of London Labour’ stance as a ploy. It could let Scottish Labour stifle vocal anti-austerity, anti-Westminster opinion in Scotland by not rocking the Westminster boat. All in the name of (I laugh) independence.

Add to that questions about why Labour has been so luke-warm about the Smith proposals, supporting the weakest and least empowering of what is surely a fudge. If Murphy believes in social justice, why didn’t he fight that corner from the start, let alone while Smith orchestrated his Commission’s fiddling. Now it’s over, out comes Jim with his rhetoric. Devo Max, what Devo Max? Long live social justice. Pah!

And then, having said all that, I really want to know why Labour can’t find common ground with the SNP (or the Greens, or the Socialists) on social justice. If, as I believe, in Scotland, it’s never been about nationalism, why not look for common cause and realise the dream together. Why the constant and pathological hatred? It's demeaning and immature. It’s not how the tide of politics is flowing in Scotland and Murphy and his band of cohorts will come undone if they don’t recognise it.

As I see it, nationalism at its worst is found in the growing jingoism of ‘Britishness’. Don't forget, Thatcher was the one who killed the 'British' project, killed British Steel, British Coal: Bathgate no more. Linwood no more. Methil no more. Lochaber no more. 

Scottish nationalism is far more inclusive and civic in nature. It’s left-leaning. If Labour can’t get behind it then they’re leaning in completely the wrong direction. We’d be able to tell better, of course, if they stopped dodging. Until I’m sure, the blue skin stays, if only to remind us of the true colour of Scottish Labour.